Report: Port of Mombasa is Not Collateral for Kenya's Chinese Loans – The Maritime Executive

Published by The Maritime Executive
Published by The Strategist
Published by The Maritime Executive
Published by The Maritime Executive
Published Apr 19, 2022 11:49 PM by The Maritime Executive
In December of 2018, a letter appearing to come from the Office of Kenya’s Auditor General leaked to the public. It carried a warning that Kenya had allegedly staked its valuable Mombasa Port as collateral for a $3.6 billion loan from China for the construction of the Mombasa-Nairobi Standard Gauge Railway (SGR). 
The revelation was serious. It emerged during the same period when reports were circulating of imminent transfer of Hambantota Port to satisfy part of Sri Lanka’s debt to China. The rumor put Mombasa Port in the spotlight as another example of “China debt-trap diplomacy”.
Although both the Chinese and Kenyan governments have denied that Mombasa Port was used as collateral, the exact loan terms for the SGR loan have remained an enigma. Hence, the rumor has continued to circulate.
However, a new report released last week by the China Africa Research Initiative (CARI) at the John Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies shows that the Auditor General erred in concluding Mombasa Port was used as the loan collateral.
“To our surprise, our team found that the collateral rumor stemmed from a seemingly tiny but critical misreading by the Auditor General (AG). The AG mistakenly labelled KPA as a borrower, responsible for repaying the SGR loans,” found the report’s authors.
For context, four stakeholders were involved in the SGR financing: Kenya’s National Treasury, the borrower; Kenya Railway Corporation (KRC), the project Company; Kenya Ports Authority (KPA), the main project customer and owner of Mombasa Port; and China’s Exim bank, the Lender. Under the terms of the contract, KPA agreed to be the SGR’s major client – not the borrower, and not the collateral.
Further, the report asserts that it is probable the AG misunderstood how a waiver of sovereign immunity – a standard feature of international commercial project finance – works in practice.
In the AG’s leaked documents, he charged that Kenya’s government had “waived immunity” on KPA’s assets, expressly guaranteeing that they could be used to repay the Chinese loan. This was a mistake, says the report.
It is rare to find an international commercial loan or sovereign bond contract that does not contain the sovereign immunity waiver clause. As one American lawyer noted, “leaving out a sovereign immunity waiver in an international commercial loan contract would be a professional malpractice.”
Essentially, the clause provides for a dispute resolution avenue in international lending. Under international law, sovereign states and the entities they control have sovereign immunity. They are generally immune from lawsuits and cannot be compelled to appear before a foreign court – unless they waive their sovereign immunity.
As an example, a published cache of loan contracts signed by Cameroon with banks and export credit agencies from Austria, Belgium, India, Turkey and the UK shows that all required similar clauses. 
Published May 20, 2022 9:09 PM by The Maritime Executive
A start-up that is promoting the use of sailing ships to provide environmentally-friendly logistics purchased a 113-year-old sailing vessel announcing that they plan to launch operations in the fourth quarter of this year. The company is accelerating its planned launch a year earlier than anticipated as it also continues to build a new sailing ship that it anticipates launching in 2023. Sailcargo purchased the cargo vessel S/V Vega Gamleby, built in 1909 that will be able to transport approximately 148…
Published May 20, 2022 8:24 PM by The Strategist
[By Anastasia Kapetas] A reading of some of the headlines on China’s new security deal with Solomon Islands might give the impression that a Chinese naval base with assets pointed straight at Australia is a fait accompli and that other Pacific dominos are just waiting to fall. Public anxiety on the issue has risen sharply—unsurprising given that the deal has been caught up in the dynamics of the federal election campaign—with a recent Sydney Morning Herald survey finding that 70 percent of voters are concerned…
Published May 20, 2022 8:21 PM by The Maritime Executive
A new bulker expected to launch in 2024 will become the first large merchant vessel to incorporate two of the emerging wind propulsion technologies to improve the vessel’s performance and reduce its environmental impact. Using both rotor sails and a rigid sail, the companies viewed it as a pilot project that they believe will be at the leading edge of the new trends in shipping. Japan’s Mitsui O.S.K. Lines’ subsidiary MOL Drybulk is leading the project working with its longtime…
Published May 20, 2022 7:15 PM by The Maritime Executive
The International Transport Workers’ Federation and U.S. Coast Guard teamed up last week to address the latest example of crewmembers stuck aboard their ships and owners extending contracts due to the effects of the pandemic. The ITF is highlighting its success at getting a dozen Chinese crewmembers repatriated thanks to the intervention of the U.S. Coast Guard.  Throughout the pandemic, there have been similar stories such as the Australian Maritime Safety Authority also working with local union representatives to repatriate…

© Copyright 2022 The Maritime Executive, LLC. All rights reserved.


Leave a Comment